A Waste of The Talent of a Generation and Slavery by “Education Day U.S.A.”


Enslaving Children By Denying them an Education

We are posting this letter to the editor as an accompaniment to our articles on the subject of enslaving children by denying them an education. We would like to thank the contributor who has chosen to remain anonymous.

September 3, 2016


Dear LM:

A Few days ago I was conducting research for a treatise and I came across an alarming online article that I encountered during my search. It had me unsure whether to laugh in derision or cry in despair. It could be headlined:

Don’t educate your children; it is the equivalent of teaching them idolatry

Some of its points are:

– To teach children science is to teach them that there are pedagogic authorities to be respected other than rabbis – which is undesirable.

– The Baal HaTanya says that secular education is worse than the sins of lashon hara and sinat chinam (slander and baseless hatred), inasmuch as the former sullies the soul, while the latter only sullies the emotions.

(From my long-ago days of studying Tanya, I remember that there were many things in it that I later came to realise did not commend themselves to humanity. This one must have escaped my attention; it astonished me to see it mentioned in that article.)

A possible solution discussed by the article’s author is to censor school text books on science. He rejects the idea – not on principle, but just as being impractical because it could backfire and defeat the purpose.

Please read the article in full – it is a real eye-opener on what drives Chabad (and other ultra-Orthodox) attitudes to secular education.

(Even more bizarre is that the author, Arnie Gotfryd, described on Chabad.org as a Chassidic Jew, is also a PhD scientist (he has a doctorate in applied Ecology) and is educational director of Maxi Mind – his own company. It’s a bit frightening – this is the second example I’ve seen in the last few days of how you can be highly educated and still have a closed mind in thrall to cult indoctrination. It makes me wonder if this guy is also a ‘born again’ Jew with Chabad as obstetrician.)

The above-linked article of his has me torn between thinking:

– let them keep their kids uneducated and unequipped for 21st century life; it will hasten the movement’s collapse or descent into irrelevancy,


– what a waste of a generation and how sad to deny innocent children what people in other countries with much fewer opportunities sacrifice so much to afford their children.

Chabad boasts about its worldwide network of ‘educational’ institutions, and in 1978 it successfully lobbied President Carter and Congress (they are experts at that) to name the Lubavitcher Rebbe’s birthday “Education Day, U.S.A.” But they are charlatans who have hoodwinked America. It is all a sham. To them, schools are not for education, they are nothing more than religious and cult indoctrination centres. If this sounds harsh, read the article and see if my conclusion still seems unjustified.


Scientism in a Chabad School?


Here are some implications of the scientific ‘principles’ listed above.

a) The Big Bang implies that creation was a one time event followed by predictable natural outcomes that do not make room for any divine intervention whatsoever. (=azav es ha’aretz)

b) Cosmology and astronomy teach that only material forces exist. Nature’s laws are viewed as fixed and unchanging since then, so everything can run by itself and there is no need for a god of any sort. (ayn Eloka) The implication is that even if there is a god, who needs him? He doesn’t do anything.

c) Accepting a 14 billion year old world casts doubt on a 6000 year old world. One of the most common outcomes of accepting this view is the belief that the Torah is not literal but only literary at the beginning of Bereishis when it says the world was made in six days. The Rebbe declares that this completely undermines the basis of Shabbos observance (ki b’sheises yamim…).

d) The Shabbos of Creation, the six millennia, are important for the idea of a seventh millennium (yom shekulo Shabbos…). In this way, those scientific views challenge faith in Moshiach.

e) These evolutionary views as well as the sun-centered outlooks picture man as insignificant in the big picture. We are only an insignificant speck in an insignificant galaxy. That’s great for the true humility we must feel but it flies against the idea of the individual changing the world. This science would have us believe, contrary to Torah, that we are insignificant and our divine service is insignificant.

f) We have a Hilchos Yesodei HaTorah that all this science contradicts in many places. Learning, reviewing, being tested on, and taking in pride in mastery of all these science views shows that there is something of higher priority in our Jewish and Chassidic minds than rabbinic authority.

That leaves us with ‘pick and choose’ Judaism, just like Reform and Conservative.

g) To say, yes but the Big Bang matches up with Genesis is simply not true. For example, the trees were created on Tuesday and the Sun on Wednesday. That is absolutely laughable to any Big Bang evolutionist.

h) These apologetic views backfire. Students don’t need equivocators teaching them nor do they need hypocrites – they need educators. The Rebbe was vehement against apologetics, and even faulted the Rambam on this. The Frierdiker Rebbe too was absolutely strident and passionate on this point in his famous 1923 letter to the Rabbis of Germany, saying it was causing spiritual holocaust (long before the physical one took place, lo aleinu).

i) The Lubavitcher Rebbe is reputed to have said, “You can explain to an American everything, but you can’t tell him anything.”

This is very relevant. There once was a time when it was enough for a parent or teacher to say about some idea, “We don’t believe in that.” Those days are gone. Everything is questioned nowadays.

Young people, especially high school students, pick up their facts and opinions from their peers and very largely from mass media. They are very impressionable and the opinions they form in high school will largely stick with them for the rest of their lives (until Moshiach comes at which time we and they will say… Oops!).

The secular world view is very clear about its rejection of basic Torah facts and perspectives and nowhere is this more apparent than in science. It’s hard enough to promote kosher and pure faith when the enemy is ‘out there’ somewhere but to invite doubts (safek = Amalek) into our schools and into the minds and hearts of our daughters and to tell them “Do well,” “Study hard,” “Do your science homework” so they can master and internalize heretical concepts which they in turn will pass on to their children raises the question of why send kids to a Jewish school in the first place?


4 thoughts on “A Waste of The Talent of a Generation and Slavery by “Education Day U.S.A.”

  1. What a waste of good, young brains! What are these so called rabbis, even the secularly well educated ones, usually bal teshuva, afraid of? If they are so confident that their beliefs and knowledge is the only truth these youngsters need, then of course they won’t naturally sway towards a secular, and non-orthodox Jewish lifestyle, when taught a skill-based, academic education.

  2. Thanks for posting the link. I think it very important to read the whole article carefully, and digest it thoughtfully. And even then, if one isn’t familiar with what actually goes on in Yeshivot, it could be quite misleading. Can all these statements simply be taken at face value? Well, at face value, it doesn’t sound so bad. Look at how he concludes the article:

    Teach the textbook with critical commentary. Perhaps the best solution, but in that case an expert in Torah, science and education will have to do the following:
    a. Writing a companion curriculum
    b. Preparing companion lessons
    c. Providing companion readings
    d. Bringing in guest speakers or a/v media
    e. Train teachers in these matters

    So he is saying that the best solution is to teach a conventional science textbook, but with the aid and and expert in Torah AND science AND education. Now it is hard to find an expert in anyone one of those three! Moreover, there is a complete lack of specificity as to what exactly will be this “critical commentary”. Therefore I have mixed feelings about where all this is going. On one hand it is good to teach science. And look, with a conventional uncensored science book! Isn’t that great? And shouldn’t all science be taught critically? Isn’t that what we want for our children? Critical thinking! So we should applaud this. On the other hand, could this so called critical commentary just turn into another brainwashing session of science mockery? And surely this too would backfire with uncertain outcomes! Nonetheless, if you know what is going one now, this article is a step in the right direction.

    • Yoel, if the ultra-Orthodox community does not want to teach their children “substantially similar” subjects than they should feel free to follow that path. BUT, they should also NOT be entitled to public funds, funds. They should NOT be entitled to ANY public funding. They should NOT be rewarded for enslaving their children, they should not be provided for so that they can be fruitful and multiply. The ultra-Orthodox should be free to live as it chooses but in so doing, they should go the path of self-sufficiency.

  3. This is the United States. Children of the United States need to know certain FACTS and have the abilities to read and write and perform mathematics at a certain level in order to merit a high school diploma. Not having a high school diploma makes it very difficult for you to obtain a job. Not having a job makes it very difficult to support yourself and your family.

    Knowing Torah is fine, but in itself does not get you a high school diploma. Knowing what the rabbis feed you also does not get you a high school diploma. These proficiencies by themselves do, however, keep you under the thumb of the cult leader.

    In my opinion, any rabbi who denigrates education is a fraud and should be defrocked.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s